Open Conversation on Political Violence, Free Speech, and Collective Memory

Over 80 students, faculty, and staff gathered on Wednesday, September 17 for the first Open Conversation of the academic year. The open conversations are times designed to provide space for the Caruso Law community to discuss the most pressing topics of the day. In keeping with that, this month’s topic was Political Violence, Free Speech, and Collective Memory. Moderated by Chalak Guinses, dean of students, belonging and career development, and Stephen White, assistant dean of student life, the time was a vibrant and nuanced discussion. Dean Guinses set the tone as "a place to be able to talk about things in the world while still at law school, hear all viewpoints, and engage in civil dialogue." Dean White then framed the conversation, sharing facts about the politically motivated murders of Minnesota State Representative Melissa Hortmann and Charlie Kirk, prominent conservative speaker and activist. 

The discussion in the room revealed many perspectives and emotions. The topics discussed included:

• How do we define “political violence?”
• What does it mean to condemn “political violence?”
• What are acceptable responses when a political and/or public figure passes, particularly from violent means?
• How is faith related to responses to political violence?
• What does it look like to move forward and create a more just society in the wake of these forms of violence?
• What are appropriate measures to enact change instead of resorting to political violence?
• How is the constant news cycle about political violence affecting you? What limits or boundaries are you practicing in response?

Dean Guinses commented on the latest talk, "The ability and opportunity to engage across difference is an essential component to the Caruso Law secret sauce and the tradition of open conversations builds those skills in our community. Our students continue to impress me with how they rise to the highest ideals of our school. They shared deeply personal perspectives, and while not everyone agreed, they did so in ways that were respectful and caring. I am proud that our students are able to engage with such pressing matters with civility and grace.”

Dean White noted, “Open conversations like this one exemplify why the Pepperdine Caruso Law community is so extraordinary.  Because our students, staff, and faculty care about each other first and foremost, they understand that they can talk about difficult topics with honesty and grace. It’s a unique part of our law school that we intentionally seek to cultivate.”